All posts
The Isthmus View

Intent and Impact

Good intent is where the conversation starts, not where it ends

Andrea Barnes
Share LinkedIn Email

If you take a minute to truly understand the concept of intent and impact, I guarantee it will change the ways you show up in difficult conversations and deliver feedback. Money back guarantee. This framing has been incredibly powerful in my life, both professionally and personally. Ensuring that your intent and impact are aligned can be an absolute game changer.

This idea isn't new, and it isn't mine. I first heard it years ago and it has stuck with me ever since. The version most of us know comes from Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton, and Sheila Heen of the Harvard Negotiation Project in Difficult Conversations: How to Discuss What Matters Most. They describe two mistakes we make with intentions. The first is assuming we know what someone else meant based on how their actions landed on us. The second is assuming our own good intentions cancel out a bad impact. In a conversation with Dave Stachowiak on Coaching for Leaders (How to Help Difficult Conversations Go Better, with Sheila Heen), Sheila Heen shares: "People with good intentions have bad impacts all the time." (I am guilty as charged and have battle scars… I think we all do.) This is important enough to pause on and repeat. You can have GOOD intentions and BAD impacts. Both can be true, and they often are.

Listen, we're all on a journey figuring out how to be humans and live and work with other humans. Very few of us wake up in the morning with the aspiration of being a relational dumpster fire. We show up with the best of intentions. The reality is, even with the best of intentions, sometimes the impact of our words and decisions isn't so great. We couldn't land the messaging, we made a bigger mess, we had an off day, we got frustrated/overwhelmed/misunderstood. This does not make us bad people, it makes us human. Self-awareness allows us to understand that even the best of humans struggle to align their good intentions with the outcomes and impacts they create. It's complex, and it's ok. What's not ok is doubling down on "but I didn't mean it!" To channel Rhett Butler in Gone with the Wind, "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn."

There's research behind why this is so hard to see in ourselves. In 2004, psychologists Justin Kruger and Thomas Gilovich published a set of studies with one of the best titles I've come across, Actions, Intentions, and Self-Assessment: The Road to Self-Enhancement Is Paved with Good Intentions. They found that people were more likely to give themselves credit for their intentions than to give others credit for theirs, and that this led people to rate themselves more favorably than they rated others. In other words, we grade ourselves on what we meant (intent) and we grade everyone else on what they did (impact).

This gets really personal quickly. Feedback is deeply, DEEPLY personal, and when someone tells us our impact wasn't what we hoped, it's easy to hear "you're a bad leader and nobody likes you" instead of "that didn't land." We get defensive, we explain what we meant, and the conversation stalls right there. I would argue that naming the intent first is what makes the impact possible to hear. Let's look at two ways to open the same conversation. "You came across as dismissive in that meeting." Or, "I know you were trying to keep the meeting moving, and that's the right instinct. I want to share how it landed with the team." Same facts, but the first one asks them to defend who they are while the second one lets them look at what happened.

If we spend our energy defending what we meant, we miss truly understanding the impact, and that is the part we can still do something about. So here's where I land the plane this week, good intent is where the conversation starts, not where it ends. Assume it more generously in others, and lean on it less in yourself.

Pause and reflect

Take a minute to reflect on a few things (I'm asking myself these too!).

  1. 01Think about a time recently when your intent and your impact didn't match. What did you say next, and did it explain what you meant or repair how it landed?
  2. 02Pick someone whose behavior has been bugging you lately. What's one good intent they might have had? Is there a way to ask them about it using this framing?
  3. 03If you have feedback to give next week, write your first sentence two ways, once with the impact alone and once naming the intent first. Which one would you rather hear?

I'll leave you with this -

"We judge ourselves by our intentions and others by their behavior."
Stephen M.R. Covey, The Speed of Trust

Take care of yourselves and each other,

Andrea

Every week I pull together what I’m reading, listening to, and learning from some of the smartest voices in leadership and AI, and I tag every one so you can go to the source (please do). I like to connect the dots on what I’m seeing out in the world.

Thanks for reading!
Subscribe to receive new posts

Thanks. You'll get an email when a new post goes up.

ANYTHING RESONATE?

Let's continue the conversation

Grab a time that fits your schedule in a few clicks.

Book time on my calendar

Prefer email? Andrea.Barnes@IsthmusAdvisory.com